• HOME
  • About
    • About Bay Shore Beach Lodge
    • About Highlands, NJ
    • Your Hosts
  • Gallery
  • Calendar
  • Reviews
  • Blog
  • Contact

10 Best Restaurants near Bayshore Beach Lodge -Highlands, NJ

See all 6 photos

10 Best Restaurants Near Bayshore Beach Lodge in Highlands, NJ

There's nowhere on the Jersey Shore that packs as much great dining into such a small stretch of coastline as Highlands and its neighbors. Whether you want your feet in the sand with a cold drink in hand, seafood with a side of sunset, or you're ready to dress up for a night out — you'll find it in one of these spots. Here's our guide to the 10 best restaurants near Bayshore Beach Lodge Highlands, NJ.

HIGHLANDS YEAR ROUND

One Willow - Fresh seafood coupled views of the bay and the NYC skyline as your backdrop. This is THE spot for a happy hourS, brunch or a special occasion dinner. The live music and sexy ambiance make it hard to leave. 20 min walk

Proving Ground – The dining patio overlooks their private beach and is a perfect spot to enjoy hearty American fare while you soak in the bay breeze. In the winter you can cozy up to one of the fire pits outside but if it’s too cold out, you can still enjoy beautiful views from their giant windows overlooking the bay.  7 min walk

Bahrs Landing Seafood Restaurant -Established in 1917 and still going strong — because when something's this good, why change it? Nestled on the bay next to the Highlands - Sea Bright Bridge, Bahrs has majestic views and is spectacular for day -sunset drinks, people watching and a traditional lobster dinner! 13 min walk

Saltwater Social — This spot a few blocks away offers creative comfort food and a great bar scene. It's got a fun, shore vibe and a huge upstairs that's perfect for larger size groups.

HIGHLANDS SEASONAL

Sandbox at Seastreak Ferry –A beach shack, a full bar, food trucks, a picnic area, and live music at this giant beach / playground for all ages right next to the ferry to NYC. It's exactly as fun as it sounds. 5min bike  

Seafarer  — This bohemian bayside lounge has one of the best vibes on the Shore — tiki bar, waterfront seating, live music & events all the time (personal fave: SaturDAY disco ). Come for the drinks, the sunset, and the scene.  10 min walk

WORTH THE SHORT DRIVE

2nd Jetty Seafood — Sea Bright. Cross the bridge and you'll find one of the best seafood spots on the Jersey Shore. Born from a crew of globe-trotting surfers who brought back bold flavors and put them on a plate, 2nd Jetty is funky, festive, and fresh. 5 min drive

Red Horse by David Burke — Rumson. Celebrity chef and proud Jersey Shore native, Burke has created a modern American steakhouse with personality. Artfully crafted food, creative cocktails, and a fireside atmosphere that makes every meal feel like an occasion. 15min drive

Beach Tavern - Monmouth Beach. Right on the water at Channel Club Marina, this gem has spectacular bay views from every angle. There's a lively bar scene, excellent seafood, beautiful pasta dishes all topped off by dockside seating that transports you from the Shore to St. somewhere. 15. min drive.

AP Rooftop — Asbury Park. Perched right on the boardwalk, the panoramic views of the ocean are jaw-dropping and the food is just as great. Grab a table before a show at the Stone Pony for a perfect Jersey Shore evening. 30 min drive

Staying at Bayshore Beach Lodge puts you at the center of some of the best dining on the Jersey Shore. You can walk to most Highlands' spots in under 15 minutes, and the short drives to Sea Bright, Rumson, Monmouth Beach and Asbury Park open up a whole other world of incredible food. Questions ? I love talking food, reach out anytime.

Bayshore Beach Lodge is a 5-star vacation rental in a prime location in Highlands NJ minutes to the bay and ocean beaches, the Seastreak Ferry to NYC and some of the best waterfront dining and shops at the Jersey Shore.

How to Book:

• Email: cherisseketchum@gmail.com or call 917-596-6798

• Response time: Will offer a quote within 24 hours

• Booking process: 50% deposit to hold dates | Rental Agreement Signed

|Balance due 30 days out | Fun begins !

• Payment accepted: via Venmo or Zelle

• Cancellation policy: 30 day

© 2026 Webready. All rights reserved.
Bayshore Beach Lodge
Highlands, NJ 07732
United States of America
cherisseketchum@gmail.com1-917-596-6798
© 2026 Webready. All rights reserved.